you call that a riot control?not to mention those incompetent commanders,not even a pulse check to mankind's greatest threat??and above all,who the heck were the geniuses that thought of making apes intelligent while enslaving them???the whole thing just makes no sense, might as well don't reveal how apes took over instead of ruining the whole saga
「They won't learn to be kind until we force them to.」
「Caesar... Caesar! This is not how it was meant to be. ↓ In your view or mine? ↓ Violence prolongs hate, hate prolongs violence. By what right are you spilling blood? ↓ By the slave's right to punish his persecutor. ↓ I, a decedent of slaves, am asking you to show humanity. ↓ But, I was not born human. ↓ I know. The child of the evolved apes. ↓ Whose children shall rule the earth. ↓ For better or for worse? ↓ Do you think it could be worse? ↓ Do you think this riot will win freedom for all your people? By tomorrow... ↓ By tomorrow it will be too late. Why a tiny, mindless insect like the emperor moth can communicate with another over a distance of 80 miles... ↓ An emperor ape might do slightly better? ↓ Slightly? What you have seen here today, apes on the five continents will be imitating tomorrow. ↓ With knives against guns? With kerosene cans against flamethrowers? ↓ Where there is fire, there is smoke. And in that smoke, from this day forward, my people will crouch and conspire and plot and plan for the inevitable day of Man's downfall - the day when he finally and self-destructively turns his weapons against his own kind. The day of the writing in the sky, when your cities lie buried under radioactive rubble! When the sea is a dead sea, and the land is a wasteland out of which I will lead my people from their captivity! And we will build our own cities in which there will be no place for humans except to serve our ends! And we shall found our own armies, our own religion, our own dynasty! And that day is upon you... now!」
you call that a riot control?not to mention those incompetent commanders,not even a pulse check to mankind's greatest threat??and above all,who the heck were the geniuses that thought of making apes intelligent while enslaving them???the whole thing just makes no sense, might as well don't reveal how apes took over instead of ruining the whole saga
与上一部矛盾之处在于,之前费尽苦心消灭了外星猿祖,现在又开始大量饲养地球猩猩做宠物,还发展成大量繁育并培养成奴隶,在矛盾之余,个人认为这一集的猩猩的种族主义色彩十分明显。同时,编剧也忽略了人类的繁衍速度,根本不需要去培训猩猩,现在地球上人类的劳动力都过剩了,还会让猩猩来抢工作?!
「Caesar... Caesar! This is not how it was meant to be.
↓
In your view or mine?
↓
Violence prolongs hate, hate prolongs violence. By what right are you spilling blood?
↓
By the slave's right to punish his persecutor.
↓
I, a decedent of slaves, am asking you to show humanity.
↓
But, I was not born human.
↓
I know. The child of the evolved apes.
↓
Whose children shall rule the earth.
↓
For better or for worse?
↓
Do you think it could be worse?
↓
Do you think this riot will win freedom for all your people? By tomorrow...
↓
By tomorrow it will be too late. Why a tiny, mindless insect like the emperor moth can communicate with another over a distance of 80 miles...
↓
An emperor ape might do slightly better?
↓
Slightly? What you have seen here today, apes on the five continents will be imitating tomorrow.
↓
With knives against guns? With kerosene cans against flamethrowers?
↓
Where there is fire, there is smoke. And in that smoke, from this day forward, my people will crouch and conspire and plot and plan for the inevitable day of Man's downfall - the day when he finally and self-destructively turns his weapons against his own kind. The day of the writing in the sky, when your cities lie buried under radioactive rubble! When the sea is a dead sea, and the land is a wasteland out of which I will lead my people from their captivity! And we will build our own cities in which there will be no place for humans except to serve our ends! And we shall found our own armies, our own religion, our own dynasty! And that day is upon you... now!」
如果有这么一天,某种来自外太空的瘟疫夺走了地球上所有汪星人和喵星人的生命,所幸人类与其他灵长类动物对该病毒免疫。若是如此,不知各位爱宠人士会如何选择。也许对养育养鸟养蜥蜴的影响不大,但那些喜欢饲养哺乳动物的人群,会不会考虑猴子猩猩呢?反正在1972年上映的《猩球征服》里人们就是这么干的。在影片的背景设定中,瘟疫基因的变异使得猿类的体型和智力均大幅提升。人类不仅将其作为宠物,还专门建立了猿类管理中心,对它们进行严酷的训练以达到服务于人类的水平,从端茶送水到整理文件等等不同层次的事务,就此埋下了抗争与革命的种子。
时间来到1991年,也就是瘟疫降临八年之后,上一部里被害的猿族博士科尼利厄斯夫妇的遗孤「凯撒」已然长大成人。虽然一直抚养庇护他成长的马戏团长阿曼多竭力避免让人类发现凯撒的存在,可是百密终有一疏。凯撒在一次口吐人言咒骂政府后大难临头,不但阿曼多不幸遇难,自己也被监禁在了猿类管理中心。即便之后因出众的智力水平而获得了一定的自由,但耳濡目染众多猿类同胞遭受的虐待与奴役,终究令他奋起反击,召集了大批猿族发动起义,攻占了管理中心并杀死了对猿类抱以极端警惕和仇视态度的布雷克州长。
从剧情上来讲,《猩球征服》应当是整个系列的重要转折点。前三部中出现的猿族代表科尼利厄斯博士和吉拉博士被新一代的猿族代表——他们的孩子「凯撒」取代,与穿越有关的部分告一段落,新的革命时代就此展开。而故事的发展也印证了科尼利厄斯夫妇的预言,人类对猿类的奴役激起了对方的反抗,于是发动武装暴动推翻了人类的统治。只可惜这么一部意义重大的影片,质量却难以恭维,尤其是在故事的铺垫和细节的刻画方面与前作有着较大差距。
当然,这样的一部作品放在彼时的时代背景下依然具有强烈的现实意义。上世纪六七十年代正值美国黑人民权运动的高峰时期,作为长期受到压迫和歧视的少数族裔,美国黑人为争取经济与社会平等权利进行了大规模的斗争。其中既有抵制、静坐、游行等非暴力形式的活动,也出现了诸如「黑豹党」那样坚持武装自卫和社区自治的团体。前段时间热映的超级英雄电影《黑豹》中「黑豹」一角的诞生就明显带有当年的时代特征,因而倍受非裔美国人的青睐。
因此,《猩球征服》中那些在政府长期专制统治、长期压迫虐待下的猿类恰似美国黑人所遭所遇的投影。同时,剧情中不但安排了一个名叫「麦克唐纳」的黑人角色帮助凯撒躲过极刑,还将第一、二部中带有反派特征的猿族彻底转化为了追求自由、反抗压迫的正面形象,这一番设计与改动显然是有的放矢的,十分符合「政治正确」。
而且,正如《葛底斯堡演讲》之于林肯、《我有一个梦想》之于马丁·路德·金,伟大的领袖总会有伟大的演讲。凯撒在率领猿族攻占猿类管理中心后也发表了一段激昂慷慨的演说:「有战火就会有硝烟,从今往后,我的臣民蜷伏在硝烟中,齐心协力,谋划人类不可避免毁灭的那一天。那一天他最终自取灭亡地把他的武器投向他同类。那一天苍天为证,你们的城市被放射性的瓦砾埋入地下,大海变成死海,大地变成荒漠。我将带领我的臣民走向自由,我们将建立自己的城市,那里没有人类生存的空间,除非伺候我们到死。我们将建立自己的军队,自己的宗教,自己的王朝,那一天已经逼近你们了!」
在本片的录像带中,保留了影片的两个结局。原版结局中,人类与猿族之间以暴制暴的压迫与反压迫永远不会结束,尽管猿族成为更加文明和拥有更多知识的生灵,他们依然不可避免地向暴力屈服。由于这一结局太过黑暗,在试映的时候遭到了观众的反对,于是才有了现在这个结局,使之成为整个系列中最血腥暴力、也最蕴含光明的一部。
除了种族问题的指涉,人类的卑劣本性是这个系列始终绕不开的话题。本片的大反派布雷克州长在被捕时恶毒地对凯撒言道:「因为你的同类曾是我们的始祖,人由猩猩进化而来,在每个人的心灵深处,仍然蜷缩着一只猩猩。这只野兽必须用鞭子降服,原始的野性必须用枷锁桎梏。你就是那只野兽,凯撒,你使我们道德败坏,你使我们心肠狠毒。当我们厌恶你,我们就是在厌恶我们的阴暗面。」这既是在咒骂以凯撒为代表的猿类,也是在直击人类的灵魂。
「人猿星球」系列中的猿类和人类恰似一体两面,你方唱罢我登场,时而你做恶人,时而我是反派,轮流坐庄,各领风骚。但不管剧情如何摆弄,无非都是在影射人类历史和人类自身。人类的掘墓人永远不会是别的物种,而是我们自己。
♑
州长说:看来这小子毕竟不是那么聪明(在整体的猿类智力测试提升的情况下怀疑凯撒已经领导了)n州长首席助手说:不,对奴隶来说太聪明从来就不是好事。n州长说:噢不要这么敏感,麦克唐纳(因为黑人运动马丁路德金刚被刺杀,但黑人问题已经开始解决,所以人的种族问题已经拿出来探讨,但人和奴隶之间的这个问题涉及到不同生物的就不在探讨的范围内,或者说人对于作为奴隶的生物是见惯不惯的习以为常,奴隶本来就没有人权,黑奴也是在占据一定生产力的情况下才能得到上层建筑的资源倾斜,但一直都无法成为上层建筑,只是其代言人或者红利的一部分)我们大家都曾经是奴隶,从某种意义上说(拉近距离?但同时作为白人的州长有没有对于奴隶制有过肯定谁知道呢,都是统治阶级的奴隶这跟地主阶级的奴隶不是一码事,最多就是统治阶级的下属)nn其实,为啥凯撒在电刑台那又杀人?就跟第三部科尔克尼斯逃出时错手杀了勤务员一样?简单粗暴的处理手法,后果是被发现猿类有杀人意向?指控杀人?凯撒再次逃脱?为啥就不能打晕呢?是为了说明猿类不顾后果的干事还是简单一根筋?还是影射人类粗暴行径犯罪的人类来说?nn为什么你们把我们从宠物变成奴隶?n因为你的同类曾经是我们的始祖。人由猩猩进化而来,在每个人的心灵深处,仍然蜷缩着一只猩猩。这只野兽必须用鞭子降服,原始的野性必须用枷锁桎梏。(人的劣根性,觉得低等的就是未开化的,只有暴力是最简单方式,就好像自己对待同族群中的弱者一样)你就是那只野兽,凯撒。你使我们道德败坏(州长不承认自己的懦弱与阴暗面),你使我们心肠狠毒。当我们厌恶你,我们就是在厌恶我们的阴暗面。(这里承认了,不愿自己的丑陋一面毫无保留地曝光出来,所以,虐待动物就是以暴制暴,想约束自己的阴暗面?)(想让凯撒也释放阴暗面,把州长就地枪毙?)n之后的大型恐吓现场,把州长还有一堆人类尸体放一起,大堆猩猩围着,拿着枪托,旁边燃烧着烈火,上窜下跳,有的还用枪托捅尸体翻身,血液横流,在头顶黑漆漆的夜空下,地上的这片广场,好像在欢颂着新时代的主角,凯撒的面容就在飘忽不定的火幕中迟疑阴沉着,看着四周的同类,对中圈的人类的恐吓没有加以劝阻,跟我们围猎动物何其相似。nn凯撒,事情不应该变成这样。(州长助手说)n这是依你之见还是我?n冤冤相报何时了。你有什么权利杀人?n奴隶对压迫者报复的权利。n凯撒,我也是一个奴隶的后代,我请求你有点人道。(非暴力不合作的典型)n但我不是人生的。(这就是你兽性应该释放的原因?)n我知道,你是进化的猩猩的孩子。n他们的孩子将统治地球。n会更好还是更坏?n你觉得会更坏?n你觉得这场暴动会为你的同类赢得自由吗?到明天…(可能就被镇压了)n到明天,那就太迟了。像飞蛾这样的小昆虫,在超过80英里的距离都可以互相联络。一只猩猩之王会做的更强一点?n就一点?你今天在这里看到的,明天五大洲的猩猩将会纷纷效仿。n用刀对抗枪?用油罐对抗喷火器?(助手这话很对,前期人类坦克镇压就行了,不过剧情需要)n有战火就会有硝烟。从今以后,我的臣民蜷伏在硝烟中,齐心协力,谋划人类不可避免毁灭的那一天,那一天他将自取灭亡地将他的武器投向他同类。那一天,你们的城市被放射性的瓦砾埋入地下。大海变成死海。大地变成荒漠。我将带领我的臣民走向自由。(这就是永远站在人类对立面,不管生态是否遭受破坏)我们将建立我们自己的城市,那里没有人类的生存空间,除非伺候我们到死。我们将建立我们自己的军队,自己的宗教,自己的王朝,那一天已经逼近你们了。